AI, Human Judgment, and the Fight for a Fair Trial | 11-17-26
Liberty RoundTableNovember 17, 202600:24:50

AI, Human Judgment, and the Fight for a Fair Trial | 11-17-26

AI can automate tasks, but can it replace human purpose, relationships, and judgment? Sam Bushman and James Edwards debate the future of work, the risks of relying on automated systems, and why increasingly capable bots may still need human direction.





The conversation opens with a lighthearted discussion about Meta and broadcast software before turning to campaign spending and funding independent media. Bushman argues that AI will create opportunities alongside job losses, while Edwards questions how workers will adapt as automation advances.





The hosts also discuss the Lindsay Clancy case, debating hung juries, retrials, double jeopardy, and media pressure. Throughout the episode, they return to a central question: just because technology can do something, should people hand over the responsibility?





Linked Timestamps


00:00 Liberty Round Table introduction


00:39 Should Sam sue Meta? A lighthearted naming dispute


02:35 New broadcasting software and the network’s production capabilities


04:49 Campaign spending versus investment in independent media


08:04 AI voice applications and the debate over bots taking control


08:51 Software failures, cybersecurity, and the limits of automation


11:56 Will AI eliminate jobs or create new opportunities?


14:35 Why human relationships and decisions still matter


16:11 Lindsay Clancy case discussion: Hung juries and retrial questions


18:37 Would people actually want bots doing everything?


21:01 The hosts debate jury unanimity and double jeopardy


23:38 Fully informed juries and the court of public opinion





Call to Action


What would you trust AI to handle, and what should always remain a human responsibility? Share your thoughts on jobs, automation, and jury decisions in the comments. Subscribe to Liberty Round Table and share this episode with someone thinking about how AI could change their work and everyday life.